Communitas

Read more

Communitas is a form of community. In contrast to the conventional, often romanticised “community”, communitas is not understood as a container featuring an inside and an outside. Instead of excluding “the other”, it embraces otherness and multitude. Communitas is an open relation to the other, the interrelationship between entities without hierarchy, without defined position within the structures of power.

Communitas subverts and annihilates existing inequalities and focuses solely on the being-in-common, but without wanting to uniform diversity. Communitas is conceptually connected to the “political” interrupting and subverting the present order. It opens up as a dissonance of perception, an interval of the unpredictable. The “political” is the place where social movement can happen, and therefore it is the place of communitas – beyond structures and hence always precarious and fleeting.

Considering concepts of communitas, however, we encounter some issues.

One difficulty is the balancing act between the common (collective) and the “own”. Roberto Esposito mentions this as he discusses the semantic core munus of the Latin word communitas. Munus accentuates the service to the common and thus pushes towards the abandoning of the personal. Communitas therefore is sometimes understood as endangering individual existence, identity and freedom – the self drowning in the common.

The dismissal of hierarchies from the idea of communitas also bears problematic potential. To concentrate theoretically on unstructured, open, and egalitarian relations may lead to the whitewashing of existing inequalities in favour of an ecstatic equality – which de facto does not exist. One might suspect that the prevalence of white male western academics among the theoreticians of communitas is not fully coincidental: their privileged position prevents the experience of discriminatory structures, leading to a conceptual neglect of inequalities that do not touch them directly.

A similar thrust shows the criticism of the conceptualisation of communitas as “coming.” As long as communitas will be constructed solely into a fleeting future, its political impetus will be ephemeral, too. Can communitas be set into present and “vulgarised” in order to gain political force? How can we fruitfully deal with existing inequalities but still work towards the political utopia of communitas?

[ Also, regarding the field of cultural studies, we could ask: how can we explore communitas in cultural practices, if it cannot exist? ]

Focusing on relations instead of a “container” leads to the question between whom relations exist or may be installed. There is first a terminological issue, whether we should speak of subjects, individuals, or even persons. Considering the core munus, the sharing of the common, it seems questionable to speak of individuals: in what way is an individual un-shareable (indivisible) if it solely consists of its con-dividuality? Do we need to assume singularities, whose only trait is to exist in common with others? At the same time, we might want to ask whether communitas extends only to human singularities – an idea not explicitly spelled out, but secretly underlying concepts of communitas. Which role do we appoint to the idea of self-responsible, conscious agency in times of anti-speciesist movements and posthuman cyber-technological developments?

Readings:

Joseph Vogl, ‘Einleitung’. In Gemeinschaften. Positionen Zu Einer Philosophie Des Politischen, edited by Joseph Vogl. Frankfurt a.M.: Suhrkamp, 1994. 7–27.

Roberto Esposito. Communitas: The Origin and Destiny of Community. Stanford, Calif: Stanford University Press, 2010.

André Lepecki, ‘From Partaking to Initiating: Leadingfollowing as Dance’s (a-Personal) Political Singularity’. In Dance, Politics & Co-Immunity, edited by Stefan Hölscher and Gerald Siegmund. Zürich: Diaphanes, 2013. 21–38.

Gerald Raunig, ‘After Community: Condividuality’. In Dance, Politics & Co-Immunity, edited by Gerald Siegmund and Stefan Hölscher. Zürich: Diaphanes, 2013. 271–279.

Durchlässige Körper und verletzliches Zuschauersein. Einblicke in die künstlerische Praxis der Choreografin Simone Truong

Durchlässige Körper und verletzliches Zuschauersein. Einblicke in die künstlerische Praxis der Choreografin Simone Truong

Die performative Praxis der Performerin und Choreografin Simone Truong lässt sich ohne Weiteres als dauernde Erforschung einer zwischenkörperlichen Sozialität ansehen. In ihrer aktuellsten Arbeit «In the Middle of Nowhere – your Absence Fills the Space» begreift sie die Migration als Zustand der Verletzlichkeit, dessen existentieller Charakter körperlich erfahren wird, der aber auch eine ständige Suche nach Gemeinschaft offenlegt. Bei anderen Performances werden spezifische sinnliche Bedingungen erstellt, wo der Akt des Zuschauens mit einer körperlichen Teilnahme einhergeht. Die Einblicke in drei Arbeiten von Simone Truong beschreiben, wie eine emergente Verbundenheit zwischen Körpern erzeugt wird – eine Verbundenheit, die zugleich die fundamentale Verletzbarkeit dieser Körper offenbart.

Read more

The Community of the Forsaken: A Response to Agamben and Nancy

India has for long been full of exceptional peoples, making meaningless the notion of “state of exception” or of “extending” it. Brahmins are exceptional for they alone can command the rituals that run the social order and they cannot be touched by the lower caste peoples (let alone desired) for fear of ritualistic pollution. In […]

Read more

What Carries Us On

Implicit within the debate on Coronavirus curated by Antinomie and archived by Sergio Benvenuto is the question—for what must we carry on?  That is, do we—humanity, which has been reckoned by many thinkers as the error in nature—carry on for the sake of carrying on?  Or, should we, following Thomas Taylor, M. K. Gandhi, Pierre Clastres, and several others, proceed with a project of returning towards a moment in history that, for Agamben, is “the normal conditions of life”. The text is part of a conversation between Jean-Luc Nancy and Shaj Mohan.

Read more

The Necromancers

The Necromancers

‘Seek unto them that have familiar spirits, and unto wizards that peep, and that mutter: should not a people seek unto their God? for the living to the dead? To the law and to the testimony (…).’[1] This passage from the book of Isaiah (8:19–20) is one of the thirteen Old Testament indications of the […]

Read more

Trailing utopia: How can an exhibition on feminist art initiate communitas?

Trailing utopia: How can an exhibition on feminist art initiate communitas?

In this article, I want to explore the ways contemporary art can produce community. By community I mean not a belonging to a specific group, but the concept of communitas as an open, unstructured, and egalitarian interpersonal bonding. The philosophical current circling around this understanding of communitas is closely tied to the Rancièrian concept of […]

Read more

Die Krise-Communitas-Schleife im Kunstkontext. Prämisse

Die Krise-Communitas-Schleife im Kunstkontext. Prämisse

Der schottisch-amerikanische Anthropologe Victor Turner war massgeblich an der konzeptuellen Herausarbeitung des Zusammenhangs von Communitas und Krise beteiligt. Die Communitas als offene, egalitäre und solidarische Gemeinschaftlichkeit sucht ethnische, nationale und sozialhierarchische Grenzen wie Geschlecht oder Klasse zu überwinden und ein Gegengewicht zur «kalten», normierenden Struktur der Gesellschaft zu bilden. Gemäss Turner basiert Communitas nicht auf […]

Read more

Transindividuality in Contemporary Dance and Performance. A lecture by Ana Vujanović.

Transindividuality in Contemporary Dance and Performance. A lecture by Ana Vujanović.

In her lecture from November 9, 2016, Ana Vujanović discusses the idea of transindividuality (Gilbert Simondon, Paolo Virno, Jason Read) as a way of thinking the relationship between the community and the individual. She focus on several dance and performance works that she uses to identify the choreographic strategies of the composition of this space in between and to consider for broader socio-political and everyday perspectives.

Read more

Das poetographische Projekt «Winterthur» – ein kommunitärer Epos

Das poetographische Projekt «Winterthur» – ein kommunitärer Epos

Das poetographische Projekt «Winterthur» zielt darauf ab, eine poetische Karte Winterthurs anzulegen, um den Namen einer Stadt mit seinen Stimmen zu füllen. Gelingen soll das durch Eydus – kurze Gedichte à 5-7-5 Silben über zentrale sowie periphere Orte, die von Winterthurer*innen eingeschickt und vom Kulturmagazin Coucou monatlich abgedruckt werden. Das Projekt startete im Dezember 2018. […]

Read more

A Metonymic Community. Towards Poetics Of Contingency

In his 2001 book with the programmatic title Community: Seeking Safety in an Insecure World, Zygmunt Bauman sketches in an almost stereotypical way a concept of community, one that not only seems to be far away, sunken into history, but that, for all that we know, might never actually have existed: a community that is […]

Read more

Image as gesture: notes on Aernout Mik’s Communitas and the modern political film

Image as gesture: notes on Aernout Mik’s Communitas and the modern political film

Walking through Aernout Mik’s exhibition Communitas, dwelling in the encounter with the people and situations in front of and on the screens, one is struck by the cinematic and political qualities of the gestures in these powerful video installations. In this article some film-philosophical reflections on the silent performative force of the image as gesture and as politics will be explored.

Read more

«Rome n’existe pas». Itinéraire d’une communauté nomade et temporaire

«Rome n’existe pas». Itinéraire d’une communauté nomade et temporaire

Lors de sa résidence à l’Institut suisse de Rome entre 2018 et 2019, la curatrice et autrice Laurence Wagner a suivi le collectif d’artistes-marcheurs DOM- lors d’une de leurs explorations urbaines dans la périphérie de Rome. Elle livre ici le récit d’une exploration célébrant le «possible» dans l’espace public et de la création d’une communauté nomade et temporaire.

Read more

The Herstory of the Black Protest. Solidary fight for democracy

The Herstory of the Black Protest. Solidary fight for democracy

The Czarny Protest (‘Black Protest’, a protest of women dressed in black) is one of the most important phenomena of the twenty-first century Poland. It is a series of events, a protracted revolution, an outcome of activities carried out by various groups and initiatives. It is linked with the past as well as the future. […]

Read more

Radical Collectivity

Radical Collectivity

Known for the invention of Starbucks, its deep nostalgia for grunge, and a Silicon Valley appeal, Seattle also has a rich Black heritage. As the city becomes increasingly expensive – and historical Black neighborhoods become white – Black artist collectives are using their platforms to address gentrification, historical erasure and ways of existing outside of those structures. Mia Harrison interviewed Ganesha from Cura Club and Saira Barbaric from Playthey and Scumtrust, three collectives that focus on the ways Blackness can be explored outside of the perpetuation of trauma narratives – through actions that heal.

Read more

Der Beat des Widerstandes. Das gemeinsame Musikmachen in sudanesischen Flüchtligslagern

Der Beat des Widerstandes. Das gemeinsame Musikmachen in sudanesischen Flüchtligslagern

Der Film Beats Of The Antonov (2014) dokumentiert, wie die Menschen in den Flüchtlingscamps in der Region des Blauen Nils oder in den Nuba-Bergen mit den andauernden Bombardements durch Antonov-Flugzeuge der sudanesischen Regierung umgehen. Dabei zeigt er auch auf, welche Bedeutung musikalische Traditionen in dieser Zeit der Krise gewinnen können. Der Essay geht der Frage nach, ob Musik als Ort einer Communitas in einer vom Krieg geprägten Gesellschaft gedacht werden kann und welche Möglichkeiten sie für den Widerstand bietet.

Read more